TlliVkifeJEWISH REVIEW
notmeed the formattan of the #04.
?JEWISH NATIONAL* FUKD
Inscribed in the Golden Book of the JewiBh National Fund, in October and November, were: Mr. and Mrs. Morris Herts, on their 60th wedding anniversary, by Mr, and Mrs. Abraham (Zelda) Land, brother-in-law and sister-in-law; Mr. and Mrs. Louis Steck (Molly), on their 60th wedding anniversary, by themselves; Allen David, son of Mr. and Mrs. J. Gottheil, by Mrs. Louis Goldfine, grandmother;^ Mark Joseph, son of Mr. and Mrs. Leo Basse), by them; Irwin, son of Mr. and Mrs. Robert Levy, by them; Neil Kalman, son of Mr. and Mrs. Mortimer iBesner, by them: Richard Joseph, son of Mr. and Mrs. Nat Finkelstein, by them: Ivan, son of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Bern, by them; Mrs. Jacob Gottlieb, for outstanding social services; Robert David, son of Mr. and Mrs. D. Coorsh, by them; Paul Allan David, son of C. Coorsh, inscribed by him; Ronald Mark, son of Mr. and Mrs. Fred Richler. by them; in memory of Max Scheffer, by his wife, Mrs. M. Scheffer; Jonathan Lyon, son of Mr. and Mrs. Emanuel Miller, by Max Miller, grandfather; Mr. and Mrs. Marvin Shaffer, on their marriage, by the Migdol Chapter of Pioneer Women. Sefer Hayeleds inscribed October     and    November
in
Rochelle Mindel, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Hershl Schec-ter, by Mr. and Mrs. William Schecter, grandparents; Karen Rae, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. S. Sacoransky, by Mrs. Tamara Kussner, grandmother; Jeffrey Mark, son of Mr. and Mrs. L. Friedman by Mrs. Bertha Rosen, grandmother; Jordanna, daughter of Dr. and Mrs. Mervin Silverberg, by her parents; Douglas Evan, son of Mr. and Mrs. M. Greenblatt, by Mr. and Mrs. Mark Greenblatt, grandparents; Leorah Miriam, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. D. Izraeli, inscribed by grandparents, Mr. and Mrs. J. L. Gewurz; Mona Sharon, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Mark Laxer, by her parents; Linda May, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. A. Rothman, by Mrs. B. Chaskelson, great-grandmother; Amy Marian, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Issie Simon, by her
15 TRUCKS TO SERVE YOU
Rl. 7-2491
B O M AC
montreal limited
770 ST. ANTOINE ST., UN. 6-1851
Producers of cuts for catalogues
$rofe�tftonal
MARION, MARION, ROBIC & BASTIEN
PftUat aaa Traaa Mark Attorney, Slat DTaauaaa4 Stmt   �   Montreal AV.  8-2152-2153
Harry Kolber
Notary
Marriage Licenses & Contract*
Oil Paz* Avaaa*. Bait* St (Safeicr BciMimr)
I Tel. VI. 4-1785 Eves. CR. 6-3468 ri^^��^^*�lat*a^Hai^*^^^^M
Patronize Review Advertisers
parent** Samuel Alexander, s6n
of Dr/ and Mrs. G. Pearl, by Mr. Heifets, Mark A. Levy, I, Poland Mr* Norman KiseU, gTaud- bAuntt Roy C. WlttstocV, DonS. pa>entjs�Reese Ellen, daughter of WoW,- Wayne Tanenbawtt. This Dr. aha - Mrs. B. Tonchln, by nat will J* enlarged irtte next
Heifets, Mark
I, 'Oel-
ISRAELI HIGH COURT RULING IN MONK'S CASE POINTS UP NEED
friends, 1�r. and Mrs. Sidney HolUman. Sefer Bar Mitsvahs in-serlhe%in October and November: Arnold, son of Mr. and Mrs. A. Sharif by Mr. and Mrs. William Bentot&grandparents; Joseph, son of Mr. > and Mrs. D. Albert, by Rachel Anna Leavy Chapter; Robert, son of Mr. and Mrs. Hernial Retch, by his parents; Benla-min, son of Mr. and Mrs. Charles Carroll, by Mrs. Sonia Milgram. grandmother; Mark Nell, son of Mr. and Mrs. N. Wexler, by Mr. and Mrs. Saul Bistritsky, grand-parents; Jerry, son of Mr. and Mrs. D. Ostrzega, by a friend, Mrs. Pahny Yoskovitz; Stephen Jeffrey, son of Mr. and Mrs. I. Frishllng, by his parents; Irwin Arthur, son of Mr. and Mrs. Milton Cohen, by his parents; Mark, son of Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin Gersovits, by his parents: Eric Donald, son of Mr. and Mrs. B. Siegal, by his parents; Mark Murray, son of Mr. ahd Mrs. Nat Ro-moff, by Rachel Anna Leavy Chapter; Rudy, son of Mr. and Mrs. Alex Melnitzer, hjr his parents; Murray David, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joel Segal, by grandparents, Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Segal; Joel Alan, son of Dr. and Mrs. Oscar Herscovitch, by them; John, son of Mr. and Mrs. I. Freedman, by Mr. and Mrs. H. B. Fried, grandparents; Howard Neal, son of Mr. and Mrs. Jack Shuster, by them; Benjamin, son of Mr. and Mrs. Leonard Silver, by them; Peter Evan, son of Mr. and Mrs. William J. Gross, by them; Leonard Stephen, son of Mr. and Mrs. B. Siegal, by Rachel Anna Leavy Chapter; Lome Leslie, son of Mr. and Mrs. Saul Eliosoff, by Rachel Anna Leavy Chapter; Hyman, son of Mr. and Mrs. L. Dubitsky, by them; Jack Samuel, son of Mr. and Mrs. T. Rosen, by them; Robert Joel, son of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Ray, by them; Seymour Bernard, son of Mr. and Mrs. Nathan Kaufman, by Mrs. Rachel Adelstein, grandmother; Jeffrey Mark, son of Mr. and Mrs. L. Grinstein, by friends, Mr. and Mrs. S. Leznoff; David, son of Mr. and Mrs. Nathan Bier-brier, by them; Victor Allan, son of Mr. and Mrs. Solomon Lumer, by them; Joel Herzl, son of Mr. and Mrs. A. Rosen, by Nochim Faierman Chapter; Craig Richard, son of Mr. and Mrs. Morris Wiener, by them; Jeffrey Brara, son of Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Finestone, by them; Jack Sheldon, son of Mr. and Mrs. Sydney Zwicker, by them; Solomon, son of Mr. and Mrs. Norman Bultz, by them.
* CANADA-ISRAEL *
Chamber of Commerce and Industry: The striking increase in Canada-Israel trade and the constructive suggestions contained in the thirty-eight  page report of the Canadian Trade Mission to Israel, were  discussed at the luncheon meeting at the Park Plaza Hotel, in Toronto. Mark A. Levy, President of Levy Industries, who is national vice-president of the Chamber, presided, Sam Steinberg, of Montreal, is president. The Hon. Eliezer Dembitz, Consul of Israel, and   representatives   of   leading banks,  manufacturing  and  merchandising companies, importers, airlines, and a number of trades and   professions   were   present. "Looking back over the total figures for 1948 to 1961", said Mr. Levy, "Canada exported to Israel, goods   for   109   million   dollars, while Israel's total exports to Canada amounted to 19 million dollars. However during the past few years, the imbalance in the trade figures is being gradually reduced. Israel's   exports  to Canada  for 1962 are likely to exceed the five million dollar mark." Many new openings for Canadian manufacturers have been pointed out in the survey made by the Canadian Trade Mission which toured Israel in 1962 and on whose experiences D. S. Wood, executive vice-president, Automotive Parts Manufacturers Association  (Canada) Ltd., who had been a member of the Mission, commented in his remarks to the meeting. Encouraged by the cordial reception the Mission encountered wherever they went in Israel and impressed by the quality aad determination of the human element rather than by the paucity of natural resources, they have come back with a clearer picture of the growing potentialities of tee Israeli market, and through Israel, of markets in some African and Far Eastern countries. Lack of space, said Mr. Wood, prevented inclusion into the report of many valuable details. However, he and his colleagues would be glad to assist interested parties with additional information. Stephen S. Barber, executive director of the Chamber, reported that during the past twelve months over one hundred ceeapanies in Canada and in Israel nave joined the Chamber which has the Canadian and Israeli Ambassadors aa their honorary   presidents.   Although, during the first year of operations the vast majority of the members was located hi Montreal, the picture js about to change fa the near future, especially as the presidency is to be rotated asaes* the
1MB. Mr. hmWmmkimm, en-
list will be enlarged in the next few months. The Toronto Branch will meet on the second week of each month when the national executive director will be in Toronto. A drive to enrol fifty to seventy members in the Toronto area will be held in the next two months.
* JEWISH PEOPLE'S * SCHOOLS
Annual meeting inianiniouslf ^e% elected Samuel Harvey as president for his tenth consecutive term. In his annual report he said that interest in-Jewish education has shown a marked increase! that "We must make a concerted effort to maintain and improve the level of Jewish education as well as injure the Provision 6f Jewish educational facilities ;'M Jewish children wherever . they may reside. Despite serious financial obstacles the Schools have hew able to continue and even to raise the existing educational objectives. The Schools have decided to maintain the five-day-a-week Afternoon Classes despite tendencies to reduce the number of afternoon school study hours. Mr. Harvey said that it is imperative to fortify the ranks of the people Interested in the School for the Folk Shule to educate Jewish children as Canadians and as Jews. Shloime Wiseman, prln6ipal of the Schools, said in his report that he is satisfied with the Day School, but concerned about the decrease of the Afternoon-School enrolment. 1 He emphasized that he is Satisfied with the Mittle Shule, whieh: hah doubled its student population, in the past three years. The Day School uses the Cuisenaire Method in the teaching of mathematics and the results have exceeded all expectations. In addition, Mr. Wiseman reported special emphasis on spoken French and a French library of books, records, plays, games, and folk-songs. He called for efforts to ensure the financial stability of the Schools, ana appealed to the community at large to help the proposed St Laurent building to become a reality for the coming school term. The financial statement showed an operating deficit of $6,500. Special tributes were paid to Shimshon Dun-sky, vice-principal; Zave Ettin-ger, executive director; Mrs. Skite-uel Alboim, president of the P.T.A.; Chaim Pripatein, chairman of the education committee. These officers were elected: honorary presidents, Israel Cohen, Morris Wasserman. Hyman Deckel-baum, Joseph Berman; president, Samuel Harvey; honorary vice-presidents, Michael Greenblatt, Jacob Torchin, Aaron Goodman; Chairman of the board, Leo Ro-skies; chairman, School Association, Abraham Parnass; Leon Tei-telbaum, Jack Berliner, vice-presidents; honorary secretary, Moishe Myerson; treasurer, Joseph Berman; educational committee, Chaim Pripstein; budget and finance, David Goodman, Charles Heft; house, Harry Yarosky; school-fee, Sam. L. 'Bernstein; advisers, Sam. Chait, Murray Lapin; Moe Bauman; executive director. Zave Ettinger; board: Mr. and Mrs. Sam. Alboim, Mrs. Harry Baker, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Ba-linsky, Israel Berman, Carl Bulua, Leonard D. Cdrdes, George Deckel-baum, Mrs. Lena Dickstein, Jack Dlusy, Sam. L. Doublet Shimshon Dunsky, Israel Eiley, Yehuda El-berg, Harry Feldman, Hyman Engel, Leonard P. Gold, Eli Kahn, Morton Katz, Nat Kopelman, Moishe Kravitz Moishe Kreisman, Mrs. Philip T. Laufer, Harry Ler-ner, Mortimer Levy, Moe Liber-man, Mrs. Wolfe Light, Dr. William Novick, Mr. and Mrs. Hershel Pepper, Joseph Rappoport, Jack Rashkovsky, Michael Rosenthal, Julius A. Rosenfeld, Arthur Rot-man, David Routtenberg, Hyman Singer, Sam. Stipelman, Issie Tan-nenbaum, Mr. and Mrs. David Vi-ninsky, Nathan Wilchesky, Mr. and Mrs. Shloime Wiseman, Jack Zuckerman.
(Continued from Pag� One)
questions in Israel. But it added, reports the New York Times,: "From extreme Orthodox to complete free-thinkers, there is one thing common to all people who dwell in Zion: We do not sever ourselves from the historic past and
Bella Cohen. 6862 King Edward Avenue; Chaim Revren-Yoisef Alt-man, at the home of Mrs. H. Klor-fine, 385 Willowdale Avenue: Hesha Berson and Rose Moss, at the home of Mrs. M. Singerman, 6822 Wilderton Avenue. This Unit met at the home of Mrs. W. Udashkin, 4836 La Peltrie Street.
*       JEWISH       * CONVALESCENT
Hospital Marcovitch and Schneider Unit met at the home of Mrs. M. Kaufman, 397 St. Joseph Boulevard West. Mrs. D. Cohen, vice-president, presided. A get-well wish was extended on behalf of Mrs. J. Levine. Mrs. D. Cohen gave a Jewish reading; and won the raffle. The next meeting will be held on Tuesday, January 8, at 2 p.m., at the home of Mrs. A. Adilman, 6280 Walkley Avenue.
*TEMPLE EMANU-EL*
Dr. Harry J. Stern, Rabbi: On Friday evening, December 28, at 8.15 p.m., Dr. Stern will speak on "Festivals Of Light." Special Chanukah music from Handel's Oratorio, "Judas Maccabaeus", will be performed; and a pageant of light will form part of the ritual program. Jacqueline Elkin, Joan Segal, Linda Gomberg, Dor-een Morris, Ellen Zion, Carol Abel-son, Judy Boston, Sherry Lynn Simon, Carl Frankel, Bernard Tarshis, Murray Perlman, Leonard Bellam, David Jacobs, Julian Leb-ensold, Mark Young, Arnold Izen-berg, will participate in the candlelight service.
*   ROSE WELFARE  * SOCIETY
At a Chanukah supper, given by Mr. and Mrs. Irving Rolter, 4180 Kent Avenue, at their home, present were: Mr. and Mrs. Max Rosen, Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Silver, Mr. and Mrs, J. GUck, Mr. and Mr*. Louis Garenk, Mr. and Mrs. H. Krakow, Mr. and Mrs. A. J. Broek, Mr, and Mrs. I. Lustgar-ten; and Hyman Rabinovitch; Mes-dames W. Brookman,Sonia Rosen-bloom, B. Naiman, Katie Cherry; and Miss Sarah Bernstein. $320 was realised. Mrs. Irving Roiter is president.
* JEWISH PEOPLE'S * SCHOOLS
Concert Society will hold the fourth of its lecture series on Tuesday, January 8, at 8:00 p.m., at the De Sola Club; Mrs. Jacob Elkin, hostess, and chairman. The speaker will be Cantor Nathan Mendelson, of Shear Hashomayim Synagogue, on "Jewish Music." Charles Lazarus is chairman of musical awards: and Mesdames Charles Belinskv, founder-president: D. Vlninsky, co-chairman; and Moishe Dickstein, and H. Rosenfeld, co-chairmen, are officers.
*MIZRACH l-HAPOEL*
, Hamixrachi: Jennie Levitt Segal Chanter meeting was at the home of Mrs. M. Epstein, 4825 Jean Brillant Street Mrs. J. Levitt, 6020 Macdonald Avenue, was hostess. Mrs. J. Blanshay, 2182 Nan-tel Street, is president.
*    FEDERATION    * OF ROUMANIAN
Jews, Women's Division meeting hostess was Mrs. M. Miller, president Present were: Mesdames T. A. Hershcovitch, C. Nadler, B. Moyse, G. Rabinovitch, H. Herman, I. Roiter, B. Marcus. C. Weiden-feld, M. Ancel, A. Finkelstein, G. Segal, G. David, R. Goldenberg, F. Wexler C. Rayfield, K. Rafc inovitch, S. Speir, C. Tarter, A. Myarovitch, N. Schwartz, 8. Ab-ramovitch, A. Cohen. A presentation was made to Mr. and Mrs, S Abramovitch. 3346 Ellendale Avenue, who celebrated their fiftieth wedding anniversary. A meeting took place at the home of Mrs, C. Weidenfeld, 4980 Maplewood Avenue.
?HOSPITAL OF HOPE*
Unit meeting on Wednesday, January 2, at 2:00 pjn U: I. Y. Bor-rin at the home of Mrs. M. Maeh-toyjteh, 8286 Linton Avenue: at 8:00 pJD-, is: Fraid-Phil. Cohen, at ^A bo�� of Mrs. J. Rmmi 4640 Planwedoe Avenue, Heft* B*setfas; on neTsday, January a,
�* *S4 �": E**"l and Max Rostrefryvhcb, at the home of Mrs.
*  ADATH ISRAEL  * SYNAGOGUE
Rabbi Charles Bender: Murray WIIHain, son of Mr. and Mrs. George Clemen. 764 Stuart Avenue, will be called to the Reading of the Torah, on Saturday, December&. in celebration of his bar-mftsvah. At the tUrty-eeeo&d annual general meeting, Joel Stem-thai, was elected president; David g. Dnbfa* vice-pretddent; Samuel Silver, parnass; Samuel Sniff, honorary treasurer; Louis Glaxer, honorary secretaxr; trustees fer a two-year term. Nathan Cohen, Issie C, Mendelsohn, Moe Iippman, Jack Steinberg and Lows TJ. Wiseman; trustees con-tinuing for another year in office: ^�JB^CISBrow�ff, Abe XerabhitHr
Goldstein, Louis Sniff aad Norman J. Trehub, Sol. W. Weber, <J.C, is honorary solicitor; honorary vice-presidsnU are; Gordon Brown, Israel N. Knight and Morris Seinek: honerary trns-jsoe, HaW Dsekolbatnn and Sol �A la his presetetJa} report, Mr. Sternthal raertfc*ed the burn-in* of the mortgage, .which took .place on October te> with a testi-saeaial dinner given In Ms honour,
ary treasurer.. tneesoe of f 127,
; e^aeheol in-
we dd not deny the heritage ox oar forefather*."
Judge, Silberg said* ^Whether he Is religious or non.rtfigloos or antt-reJSfetofc * Jew to bllically to historic Judaism fronV which he derives bis �f
cording to which be celebraW Us festivals, and from whjwe giants of thought and moral heroes his nati6nalpride is nourished/'
The Judge asserted that Brother Daniel would continue to� be a "lover" of Israel, but that his integration into Jewish Israeli society and his "sincere love" of it would not take the place of the "inner identification that is lack-ing."
The judge held that "the basic concept that Jew and Christian are two titles that cannot be combined into a single subject is com* mon ground both to the ordinary people and to the scholars."
Brother Daniel escaped from the Nasis and took refuge in a convent in Poland where he was converted to Catholicism; He became a Carmelite monk In 1946 and came to Israel in 1969.
Last March, his appeal to the Ministry of Interior for Jewish nationality under the Law of Return was denied under a Government administrative directive, stating that a person who belongs to another religion cannot be registered as a Jew in Israel.
It was this qualification in the Government's directive that Judge Haim Cohn argued against in his dissenting opinion. The judge asserted that the qualification was outside the authority of the Government and not binding in law, says the New York Times. "The law should be carried out as it is in its simple meaning without the term Jew being accompanied by any religious content or qualification," Judge Cohn wrote.
Judge Landau asserted in his opinion that "the petitioner has excluded himself from the community of fate of the Jewish people and bound up his destiny with other forces with whose orders he complies."
Judge Landau expressed doubt that the Talmudic saying that "a Jew, even though he has sinned, remains a Jew" was meant to apply to a convert. In any case, he said, the question was one to be decided according to civil law.
Following are excerpts from the majority and minority opinions by Israel's Supreme Court:
The great psychological difficulty we encountered from the beginning of this unusual case � paradoxically enough � lies in the great sympathy and deep gratitude that we owe as Jews to Oswald Rufeisen. the convert, "Brother Daniel," the applicant before us.
How-can We refuse this nian his
Seat heart's desire, to completely antify himself with the people that he loves, and to be naturalized, not a foreign immigrant but a Jew in the land of his dreams?
But this great appreciation must not serve as a means for desecration of the name and content of this concept "Jew."
We see that what Brother Daniel requests us to do is to draw . a, line under the sacred historical meaning of the name Jew and to deny all the spiritual values for which we have been martyred.
The question before us in its naked legal simplicity is: What is the meaning of the term "Jew" in the Law of Return of 1960, and does it include a converted Jew who has been baptized as a Christian, but who regards and feels himself as a Jew despite his apostasy?
I shall say at once that were I to agree to the applicant's alternative argument, that the term Jew in .the Law of Return has a meaning identical with the religious meaning of this term in the rabbinical courts' jurisdiction law of 1963, I would propose making the order nisi absolute and order the Minister of the Interior to grant the applicant immigrant status.
The prevalent view in Jewish law is, in my opinion, that an apostate is regarded in law as a Jew in all respects, except perhaps for a few marginal rules that are of no importance for the question of principle.
The term Jew in the Law of Return has a different meaning from that term in the rabbinical courts' jurisdiction law. The latter has a religions sense in the meaning accorded to it by Jewish law, while the former has a secular sense in the meaning of the ordinary usage of men, and I add and stress � in the ordinary meaning in the mouth of Jewish men.
The reason for this is clear. The rabbinical courts' jurisdiction finvolves] the application of Jewish religions law to Jews.
It is obvious that in this context the questions of "who is a Jew?" must also be solved according to Jewish refigionelair.
It is not so in the Law of Return. This law is a secnlar law aad its terms hate to be interpreted accoHKae; to otvJ&ary mmriag, except fas nanstaal Bases.
BetMs* the Lair of Retom b Ira original Israeli saw it is reasonable to interpret the term "Jew* as we the Jews e*dertttnd H.
The fjeestion fs what 1s flu* or* dinary Jewjsh Maitm* of the tens Jew, aad dees it fiishsae an apostate?
Tha answer is b my view dear-cut: a Jew who eeshraeed the Christian faith enaaot he tailed a Jew.
msa extreme orthodox to
If^^^J^^tP heritage
arY eating K$e a*�eW cttl-tttre. A Reople almost as old as httnaplty dose aot; start' ab ovo, (from- we egg), and our new culture in this country will even In extrtnie eases be only, a 4iew edi-
tioif of otrr past culture;'   .
The^applicanVa counsel has argued that non^recognition of his client's Jewish nationality means turning Israel into a theocratic state. Israel is hot a theocratic state, because it is net religion tbal^reg^latea the eltisens' life,
The case 'before, us proves this. H*d.ye applied the categories of religions law to the applicant, he would have been considered a "Jew."
There are differences of nuance and approach among scholars, one can agree or differ with them, but the lowest common denominator is that no one can regard an apostate as belonging to the Jewish people.
The healthy instinct of the people and its will to survive is also responsible for this general axiomatic view. For experience teaches us that apostates are destined ultimately to be cut off completely from the nation's family tree for the simple reason that their sons and daughters marry members of other people.
Concurring Opinion:
If I could follow my heart I would grant the applicant's wish but to my regret I am not free to do so, for I have to interpret the term "Jew" in the Law of Return not according to my wish but in accordance with what I believe to have been in the minds of the legislators.
The applicant's affiliation to the Jewish people is from his view-
Soint true and sincere. He is of ewish origin, was brought up as a Jew and a Zionist, worked and suffered as a Jew and even when embracing Christianity, he did not sever his family ties and did not attempt to exclude himself from the Jewish community.
In my view aU_this-should suffice to open~~th~e gates of the country to him as immigrant and for his registration as of Jewish nationality.
The people, with its well-developed instinct of self-preservation, have ruled otherwise. For the Jewish people, a Jew who has gone over to another religion has excluded himself not only from the Jewish religion but also from the Jewish nation and has no place in the community of Israel. In the mind of the Jewish peo-
Sle, a Jew and a Christian cannot well within one person. I believe it is this spirit that permeates the Law of Return and the Knesset, when using the term Jew, Intended the word in this popular meaning.
My final conclusion is therefore that a Jew who has changed his religion cannot be considered a Jew in the Law of Return and as it is understood today by the people.
Dissent:
I agree that according to Jewish religious law, an apostate is a Jew.
I also agree that the Law of Return [and the residents registration ordinance] have to be interpreted according to the rules obtaining in the Israeli courts with regard to all legislation of the Knesset
But I cannot agree that such interpretation of the Law of Return requires or permits us to deny to the applicant the rights of s Jew.
If I correctly understand my honored brother we shall never be able to regard as a Jew whoever adopts the Catholic faith and joins its orders. Even though it is no longer la theory or in practice our enemy, the Church cannot deny its past just as we cannot deny our past, aad a Jew and a Catholic will always remain contradicting terms.
I do not subscribe to this "historical continuity."
If history continues, and cannot be severed from its beginnings, this does not mean that it does not change and progress and develop.
The New York Herald Tribune reported: The lone dissenting justice, Haim Cohn, observed that if Brother Daniel "will pack up his robe and hide hJs cross and conceal his faith, the gates Would be opened for him and none would say a Word. .But he cornea openly, sincerely, and he finds the gates locked.
Justice Cohn quoted Isaiah, 8:2: "Open the falsa and lit the righteous people come in." He argued that under the Law of The Betara the tarsi Jew aaetJd not be aceesipasdsd to rslhrloee content at ralig^ lantatttesss. . The eeoxt, axterits reference to peraeeasioB of the Jewa dor-tag the leejnisitsoo, aad to those Jewa who deed rather than ac-
to �pre-
---Jhff* by
.that -we have nonpar-rel with the Cathelk Charch. And we da not, Heaven fetttTi*sntffy taeawMtsra chareh <* JohnTx wf� the sneeistal Popes"
31� eoert added that K dees not gjy^gy the cwert Mslaea
(ChUMI s* Pm�e Nme)